Guilty Crown – 15 Review

Oh, thank god, that isn’t awkward at all with Souta being right in front of him who would be part of the so-called ‘trash’… Shuu really knows how to be a jerk.

Guilty Crown 15 – Shuu Finds Out That Being Kind Is Pointless

So, ever heard of the cautionary tale called “The Kind King”? Well, it’s about this king who didn’t understand the most fundamental lessons about economy and therefore ended up destroying his own country by trying to improve it. He wanted to make his people richer and their lives more comfortable – but instead managed to make the situation even more miserable than it already was (since he helped them because they were whiny). So the ‘Kind King’ isn’t a king anymore because his kingdom disappeared by giving everything away that made it his kingdom and nobody calls him ‘kind’ anymore either because life is more terrible than ever. But somehow Hare starts fantasizing and insists on her belief that this ‘Kind King’ is actually a great guy. Well, he isn’t – because he sucks at his job. Problem is, though: We’re talking about Guilty Crown. And I have this uncomfortable feeling sometime in the future Shuu will change his opinion again about what being a king means and being kind is considered a good move again.

Synopsis:
As Shuu hears about the Void-ranking-system he immediately realizes that he has to make a decision but can’t do that… because he’s Shuu. So he agrees with Yahiro when he’s with him and agrees with Souta when he’s with him and ends up deciding nothing. But Souta fears what the ranking-system will do to his life since he’s Rank F (which means “trash” to quote Shuu) so he gathers the rest of the Rank-F-candidates and they talk Shuu into releasing their Voids and Souta & Co leave the school-grounds to show the world how useful they can be. Shuu meanwhile retreats to his hideout which is still untouched despite all the shit that has happened in Tokyo the last few weeks. Hare after talking to Tsugumi and Ayase in a blatant fanservice-scene decides to find him and of course knows exactly that Shuu would be in his hideout. There she tells him of her favourite fairy-tale “The Kind King” (which has a kind of a bad ending but well…) and admits that she loves him. They are interrupted by a call telling them that Souta and the other “trash” have left the school-grounds. Funny thing is, though, that the Anti-Bodies choose this time to start another half-assed attack and when Shuu finds Souta & Co together with Hare they are attacked. They blunder around and most of the “trash” dies and Shuu protects Hare from a rocket but leaves him badly injured. Hare uses her last reserves of power to heal Shuu and ends up turning into a crystal. As Shuu wakes up he finds her dead and goes nuts. He repels the attack using Inori (who was, as always, just there during the episode leaving no impression at all on me…). After the battle he beats up Souta and blames him for what has happened and he decides it’s time to be badass.

The distinction between trash and better people, that is… It’s really strange how the series doesn’t insist on making it look evil. It’s interesting to see the series consider the “necessities of evil” but I would’ve liked to see a little bit more resistance to the plan than “Let Shuu decide it.” from the people who don’t end up Rank F.

Review:
Guilty Crown is already heading for the finale obviously with starting the depression-phase. Seven episodes are left but somehow I can’t shake off the feeling that the finale of this show will be just as convoluted as the semi-final was. One thing Guilty Crown never has is this feeling that it has a story to tell. In this series stuff happens in a very whimsical way that never gets any build-up or anything I would seriously call foreshadowing. Guilty Crown somehow manages always to want to do so many things at the same time that it just can’t decide what it wants to do when it has to decide. Not only that it creates a kind of chaotic spontaneity (like Code Geass but without any funny exaggeration) but it crushes any hope of using the full potential of some episodes which are actually good.
And this one is actually surprisingly solid but like with the good semi-final Guilty Crown crushed any hopes long ago of doing anything right no matter how good some episodes are on its own. This episode’s plot-structure is solid, though, by using the usual pattern. First you have the wimpy main-character who has to make a decision, then you have the group of people depending on the decision and another group who want him to decide for the other option. The main-character feels tortured and doesn’t know what to do and that’s when one of these “understanding female characters” turns up and the usual “Be yourself”-routine. But because the wimpy main-chara waited too long one group of people does something stupid and the main-chara tries to take care of the stupid stuff they’ve done. And while doing that shit hits the fan which leads to a dramatic event which traumatizes the main-chara and he starts now the “Uuuh, the world is SOOOO bad.”-routine becoming a badass. On the paper the episode actually is okay and it’s a good way to explain the change of the main-character into Mr. Badass for the sake of depression in the pre-final-phase.

You have to admit, fantasizing that the anti-social wimp in your class is supposed to be some sort of “great king” is kinda delusional, right? A flashback might’ve been nice to show why Hare showed so much interest in Shuu in the first place. Her self-proclaimed understanding of Shuu’s “good points” is quite miraculous considering she avoided him at school and Shuu… was pretty much a jerk the whole time.

Now I said it’s okay on the paper because it’s still Guilty Crown and one thing this series always sucks at is – build-up. Since the Void-number-thingy came out of nowhere in the last episode I’m still not quite sure what the point is of all this. Weren’t Void supposed to be the expression of a person’s heart? So why the hell can you rate that kind of thing now? Well, not like it’s totally untypical for a shounen-series to do that but usually it’s done with generic vague jargon like chakra, reiatsu, whatever… In this series, though, apples were turned into oranges simply because it was convenient for the story. And the way the F-ranked-people feel the need to be useful is also something that practically comes out of nowhere because this Void-ranking-system was mentioned last episode and it’s rather vague and not really clear what exactly it means. So the F-Ranks-people’s motivation ends up being a generic “We don’t want to be last…!”-statement which sounds more like whining than rebellion against discrimination. I mean this school totally depends on Voids now apparently, they even need Voids now to open cans which is really stupid. And just like that the meaning of Voids totally changes because in the beginning it sounded more like Voids are people’s hearts but without any build-up things changed into this. That way the pacing of the episode seems rather rushed since things don’t happen because it makes sense in this setting but because it’s convenient for the plot to let this happen now.
Aside from the bad world-building there’s also a problem with the way the characters behaved in this episode, I think. Aside from Shuu who was just wimpy and couldn’t make the decision everyone was either stupid or far too passive. There was a real problem with character-interaction in this episode because there wasn’t really any. This episode was dictated by things happening and characters commenting on it. One could blame the lack of consistent world-building or the fact that there was no dramatic build-up to this turn of events but the characters basically just ‘followed the script’. There was no natural dynamic in this episode which made the characters come alive. Shuu’s struggle was between doing the necessary evil thing and… doing nothing. Souta wanted to do something against that by taking a group of F-people to go to a random hospital in a warzone in the unlikely case of finding vaccine there. Yahiro just keeps nagging Shuu and repeats himself by saying how necessary and important the ranking-system is. And the rest waits for Shuu to decide and actually treats him like a ‘king’ although I don’t feel he already has earned the right for that treatment – although he’s ‘special’ with his Void-number. But these characters were stuck in these roles and just did what was necessary for the story. There was no real characterization for the sake of characterization, you know, stuff that simply reminds you what makes Shuu Shuu, Souta Souta and so on.
Speaking of roles there’s of course Hare with her tragic death and the introduction of the king-trope. Before that the only hint that this series has anything to do with a king was the fact that it’s called Guilty Crown and that Shuu has the King’s Power (way back in the beginning it was called that) but there was never any kind of metaphor, analogy or symbolism going on in relation to Shuu. This changed now with the ‘Kind King’-story from Hare who nicely makes it very obvious what it’s supposed to mean. I have to admit though that if you want to make a story about a king who cares about his people and is full of mercy and stuff there is quite a few better stories to do that than the one Hare chose to tell – because seriously her story was about a king who sucks at his job. He ends up being hated and he destroys his own kingdom. If you ask me that sounds more like a story about why being kind is pointless instead of why it’s good to be kind. And Hare kinda made it sound like it was about that. Her fluffy interpretation sounded more like being kind is the right thing to do no matter what the repercussions are. I’ll refrain at this point explaining how this story could also be interpreted as foreshadowing for the final because I want to mock it when they actually use this foreshadowing. It’s not likely, I think, since this series never understood the purpose of build-up.
In the end this is actually one of the better episodes of Guilty Crown, though. The groundwork for this episode is solid and things make sense in a very open-minded way. You actually have plot-development and the characters develop as well in a way that makes sense in the context of the episode. But like usual the biggest problem is the greater picture of being consistent in terms of world-building and characters. Like that this episode actually does go into the right direction plot-wise but ends up just blundering through this episode’s plot. Guilty Crown never much cared about the long-term stuff or character-development that isn’t introduced as sudden as plottwists.

A solid episode but the lack of build-up makes it hard to not frown at the sudden developments. The characters are reduced to being stiff actors in a rather obvious play trying to be very dramatic which makes it hard to sympathize with them. This episode just rushed through the motions of preparing the stage for the final which is sad because this episode was one of the better ones compared to many other Guilty Crown episodes.

Episode-Rating: 5,5/10

On another note I have to say one good thing about Guilty Crown: Its soundtrack is actually really frigging good.

Composed by Hiroyuki Sawano the soundtrack (the translated liner-notes can be found here at the anime instrumentality blog) also features a surprising number of vocal tracks with various artists. I have to admit that watching the series I didn’t notice the soundtrack at all which perhaps shows how bad the storytelling in that series is when it can’t even make use of this good soundtrack. I listen to many soundtracks but I don’t know that much about music so I will refrain from rating the soundtrack (just consider it a cautious recommendation). But to offer a list of favourite tracks with which you may want to start to find out whether you like the soundtrack or not: Omega, Basileus, Krone, Release My Soul (feat. Aimee Blackschelger).

Advertisements

About M0rg0th

We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.

Posted on February 3, 2012, in Anime, Guilty Crown, Reviews and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. 15 Comments.

  1. nice eps, too bad Hare had to die, but that is what u can xpect from a character that
    can heal stuffs, such as Orihime from bleach, tho she doesnt heal cars.
    she somewhat *need* to die, since her ability would put any team at a great
    advantage.

    I love it when shu turns badass like that, the weak people from the school is not just weak in terms of their void, but also their character, attitude and all. if anything, they should be caged for their own good, letting them do what ever they like, they will do something so stupid, it will cost even someone’s life not just their own.

    well, isnt this show is set for second season?

    this episode is better.. unlike the other episodes.

    Like

    • Yeah, you’re right, her Void could heal or repair pretty much anything, it was overpowered but then again the Void-concept was never a really balanced one to begin with. Actually I’m kinda glad she died because that way there’s no silly love-triangle-drama when Shuu’s and Inori’s relationship starts being important again. Then again her characters was far better than Inori’s who has no presence or charisma at all. Only when I typed the synopsis for the episode I remembered she was even present in this episode, she really doesn’t leave much of an impression as a character.

      Yeah, not that it’s plausible character-development, it’s a bit too drastic for that but I guess him kicking ass is definitely more entertaining than him being indecisive and whiny.

      It is? I’ve thought it would be just a 2-cour-series… Do you still have the link for the site where you read this?

      Like

  2. well, from some interview back then.
    can i paste the link?
    here:

    http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interview/2011-11-28/interview-koji-yamamoto-ryo-ohyama-and-george-wada-on-guilty-crown

    actually i am not too fond of this show, at least not actually yet, i mean this show is
    kindda interesting and all, but it tends to waste lots of screen time on something not
    particularly important, my most disappointing part of this anime is that when since the beginning, they try to make this mysterious girl character, and only introduce her finally in one episode, as Mana and then that it, its like playing with viewers emotion, mana is introduced in one episode and was quickly killed. what is the point of the mysteries from the beginning… sigh,.. sigh..

    maybe i was hoping too much from anime.. lol

    Like

  3. No, it’s two-cour. The interview means that it’s 22 episodes (instead of the usual 11 episodes that Noitamina series gets). There will be no second season.

    Like

  4. who is the autor of the tale “the kind king” ?

    Like

  5. I totally Agree with you about the soundtrack, it’s amazing. One of the best I’ve heard so far indeed. It easily surpasses many high-budget films. It’s sad such a good soundtrack is not used at it’s full potential. (I’m a theory loving musician, if knowing that serves any purpose.)

    Anyway, there’s one thing about GC I think they’re pretty good at (Story-telling area), which I believe is something hard to find on the average shounen series: Things tend to go on the opposite direction from what the characters make you think will happen.

    For example, when the F-Team said they would show they were capable of something, and Shuu told them to use their voids to fight, I was expecting some crappy scene where they would actually fight, defeat the anti-bodies somehow with their low rank voids, and everyone would be happy or whatever. But they actually WERE useless characters whose stupidity screwed up everything. Same happened when Shuu said he would protect the other guy’s brother, and got him killed instead. I mean, it’s probably the only real reason why I’ve enjoyed some episodes… I remember I was on the edge of my seat after the second example occurred. They make good use of plot twists in simple but critical situations. (and having such a low expectation for Guilty Crown also helps to make those situations surprising)

    BTW M0rg0th, thanks for all these reviews. I don’t really like commenting on websites, but I felt I had to say this. I actually watch some series (such as Guilty Crown) to help me avoid making the same mistakes while writing Stories/Scripts, or learning about what makes a story good or bad. Every review you make adds something new onto the ‘not to-do’ list. So yea… Thanks a ton for helping me develop auto-critical skills.

    Like

    • Hiroyuki Sawano has also released an original album called “Musica” and listening to it, I have to say: this composer is one to look out for. I can’t say I noticed any of his work before (didn’t notice any good music in Blue Exorcist as well for example) but he’s certainly now on my list of good composers.

      Yeah, you’re right that the storytelling was quite good in this episode and this episode is pretty good overall. What Guilty Crown lacks is the ability to build up drama. Every episode had another focus, there’s always something else to talk about and there’s no unifying purpose as to what matters in the moment. It simply depends on the episode what matters right now. For example, the ranking-system is supposed to improve the situation but nobody seems to think beyond that, they have the ranking, important people get better treatment than trash – and then what…? Well, it’s not like they have to hurry since the Anti-Bodies just start these half-assed assaults all the time when it’s convenient for the plot. Since it’s the writer of Code Geass it might be too much to ask to get some logical plot-development but Code Geass was at least epic and exaggerated. Guilty Crown, though, wants to be rather dark and grim and only succeeds in some episodes to do that like this one. But the rest of the series just drags these flashes of brilliance down.

      Always a pleasure 😉 ,

      Like

  6. What a hot mess this anime is.
    Yeah, it’s a good learning.
    Don’t make the same mistake! (when we write story someday)
    This anime is merely a pack of action scenes. It doesn’t have any build-up / foreshadowing to what the hell is going to happen in the end / what the hell happened as a whole.
    – What’s purpose of these crystal disease? Couldt it be that alien want to use it to take over the world? But of course, there’s no sign of that.
    – What do Scarface and mr. President want from Shuu? Kill him? Puh-lease, just drop an atomic bomb unto that school. Capture him alive? Oh, there are so many chance of that, yet you guys didn’t do it.
    – What kind of exciting final fight are we going to see? Scarface, Daryl and president are just normal humans. There’s that creepy kid from semi-final, but he didn’t even bother to jump in the fight last time.
    Idiot. Idiot author.

    Like

    • Hey, what’s with the Kind King-story as foreshadowing? It foreshadows that at some point Shuu might realize that the Dictator-routine doesn’t quite work and decides to be the old Shuu again… which means the kind of King who sucks at his job. Well, the series probably won’t see it that way but that’s Guilty Crown for you.

      What’s purpose of these crystal disease? Couldt it be that alien want to use it to take over the world? But of course, there’s no sign of that.

      After Daath’s appearance in the semi-final I had this theory that it’s an alien-material that destroys most of humanity but would evolve the rest into a post-human state meaning that Shuu and Daath are supposed to be the next stage of human evolution. You could call it mutation but then everyone would make X-Men-jokes about the series, therefore it’s long-winded evolution even if it takes place in a short amount of time. But I guess that might be a little bit too elaborate for the kind of story Guilty Crown wants to tell…

      What do Scarface and mr. President want from Shuu? Kill him? Puh-lease, just drop an atomic bomb unto that school. Capture him alive? Oh, there are so many chance of that, yet you guys didn’t do it.

      Don’t forget the “miracle-wall” that somehow can move through the city 😉 . They don’t really need to do anything actually but it sure would help the process if when they do something it wouldn’t be another one of these half-assed assaults we’ve seen until now.

      What kind of exciting final fight are we going to see? Scarface, Daryl and president are just normal humans. There’s that creepy kid from semi-final, but he didn’t even bother to jump in the fight last time.

      Obviously that Daath-kid is the final boss since he has the same power as Shuu but (of course) not his Shuu-ness which will decide the fight in favour of Shuu. You know, the thing is, Daath actually knows how to do his job, Shuu doesn’t which makes him the Kind King and therefore the automatic winner of this fight. And I really hope that the better king being one who sucks at his job will be a cheesy unsubtle cheer for democracy, that’s just the kind of thing Guilty Crown’s final needs 😀 .

      Like

      • And don’t forget that Inori is actually a crazy who would kill school boys without holding back. Even though her existence is so faint this episode, I wonder what role she’s going to play. But hey! Isn’t she just an empty shell created by the baddies to be filled by Mana’s soul / personality? The author is making up whatever he wants. 🙂

        Like

  7. You know, the more I hear about this show…the more I’m glad that I stopped watching it after the first episode.

    Like

  8. eterychan, the boys tried to rape her, she killing them is an act of self defense.

    Like

  9. I desperately try to see reason in your opinion of this series but all I see is someone blatantly bashing a series for what it intended to do all along and who actually praises Shuu for losing his mind. He didn’t become a worthy king, he lost it, that’s it. It doesn’t make him a decisive leader, it makes him a cold-hearted leader.

    I commend this series for taking such a drastic turn for its main character, I suspect that while he may not revert (at least not until somewhere along the final episodes) back to his old self he may do a slight re-configuration of his personality. Either that or he reverts back in the very next episode with a small tweak.

    As for Hare, I don’t really feel she’s too bland in any way. Sure I’ve seen her type of character before, but not to the point where I don’t recognize her presence, the exact same thing goes for Inori except she looks so different that you automatically notice her whether you want to or not. Either way, Guilty Crown have just recently gone into the second season and people are finding things that don’t make sense, would it be too much to believe that the answers will come further up?

    Like

    • Either way, Guilty Crown have just recently gone into the second season and people are finding things that don’t make sense, would it be too much to believe that the answers will come further up?

      Considering how the series behaved in the past: yes 😀 .

      Like

  10. The soundtrack is amazing, but the overall story is lacking, and its such a shame considering the animation is very well done.

    I am surprised you rated this ep. 5/10 considering your overall review sounds like it should have been less….

    Like

Please Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: