Hibike! Euphonium S2 – 05-08 Review

hibi 0501

Then simply don’t do it!

Hibike! Euphonium 05-08: And with that, the ensemble wins another competition!

And… since this wasn’t the Nationals, literally nothing has changed for the ensemble. I guess, they just have to continue being try-hards and it will all be fine.

BUT!

Asuka’s mother raises her daughter alone and has decided to start some trouble. Trouble, which keeps Asuka away from the ensemble despite her wishes. And Kumiko’s sister’s in trouble because she has stopped playing the trombone despite her own wishes all those years ago! What a coincidence!

Also, Taki has a dead wife. Good to know and… that’s really all you need to know about that character.

Review:

hibi0502

You know she’s doing something wrong because she’s a real asshole in this scene. A hooray for subtlety!

The theme is a big part of any narrative. What is it that ties all things together? How can any plottwist no matter how confounding still end up contributing to the story? What will be the takeaway from the narrative after all is said and done? That’s where the theme comes into play. And I’ve talked plenty about Hibike Euphonium’s theme of passionate professionalism. But with Asuka’s arc, the series is entering familiar territory thematically – and seems to have nothing new to say about it.

Before that, though, the series has delivered two much-needed “filler-episodes” which are light on plot and story-development. Instead, the episodes take a break from any melodramatic problems and take its time exploring the characters. In this regard, the fifth episode is closer to a “filler-episode” than the sixth with its exploration of Taki’s past. But both episodes don’t have the same urgency the story-arcs usually have in this series.

Especially the fifth episode does something this series is still lacking most of the time: characterization beyond its direct link to the music. What makes the series feel shallow more and more is its isolationist attitude towards characterization. Most of the time, anything that hasn’t to do with its passionate professionalism is seen as a distraction or even a disturbance. Characterization ends and starts with the character’s relationship to this philosophy at the core of the series. And so, it’s good to see Taki have a motivation that is a tad more complex. Not that the idea of fulfilling a dead person’s wish or feeling a general obligation towards such a person is a fundamentally fresh idea. But it gives Taki depth in a way very few characters have in this series.

It’s a sad thing how having an answer to “Why does this character give a shit?” is a rarity in the series’ characterization. Sure, basically all the story-arcs concern itself with a character dealing with their attitude towards the ensemble and its demands. But here’s where the theme feels more like a roadblock than the guideline for consistency it should be. The passionate professionalism at the heart of the series is all the series cares about. Once a character has learned to understand what the theme of the series is, all problems of that character’s life get solved. Even how the story-arcs have approached that theme thus far cements the theme’s inflexible nature. Despite the series’ progression, the series hasn’t yet questioned or deconstructed that theme (the closest thing to that is Kaori but it isn’t portrayed as a counter-point). Instead of using its story-arcs to offer another point-of-view, showing another path towards the theme or adding more depth to the theme (by for example showing how it impacts other aspects of the characters’ lives), the theme of the series is a rigid ideal that every character is supposed to aspire to. And all the variation the series has is to tell us that any deviation from the ideal leads to failure.

Asuka’s story-arc in the seventh and eighth episodes is a good example of that. What makes it one of the series’ stronger arcs is Asuka herself. Here’s a character who does have layers (like Taki). Her cheery personality, her sense of humor, her secret cynicism, her complicated home life: All of this amounts to a sense of depth many of the other characters are lacking. And having to decide between her passion for music and her emotionally frail mother’s tantrums is a good basis for drama.

hibi0503

Of course! You give up a ton of free time, you have to deal with the harsh judgments of the teachers, you have to bear the weight of everyone’s expectations and you have to finish school at the same time… But whatever, it’s no biggie if you end up getting nothing out of this. It’s all about the journey, isn’t it? And trying really hard without winning any competitions and awards is a great story to tell to your grandkids.

Where it all falls apart is the utter lack of subtlety and the sheer amount of symbolism the audience gets drowned in here. The story in those two episodes is forceful to the point where a lot of moments might as well have a flashing subtitle across the screen saying “GET IT?!”. This story-arc is laying it on SO thick, you have to fear that either the writers think the audience is full of morons or they can relate to the story-material so little, they’d think this is the amount of storytelling needed to explain what’s going on.

Where to even start…? First of all, Kumiko’s sister and Asuka basically have the SAME story-arc but they’re on opposite ends of that arc. Real life is keeping both from really doing what they want. It’s just that the sister is the future version of what would happen if Asuka were to really quit the ensemble. This would be less of a problem if Kumiko were aware of that or (better yet) we’d actually follow one of those characters in the story. Again, though, we have to follow Kumiko getting her shit together over the course of multiple episodes just so that she can be instrumental in confronting these characters with their flaws. Meanwhile, the story is pounding the audience repeatedly with its symbolism (the Euphonium-CD, the phrase both Asuka and Kumiko’s sister use) and the way the sister talks about the trombone. It’s frustrating to watch. Especially because Kumiko shows neither empathy nor compassion for Asuka or her sister and is instead just curious and confused. It’s safe to assume that at the end of the eighth episode most of the audience is multiple steps ahead of Kumiko in understanding what is going on and what should be done to change that.

I have to say that I like the idea of Kumiko as the protagonist more than what this series has done with her. The eighth episode is the worst one in that regard. At the beginning of the first season, Kumiko had been a very carefree and reluctant “hero”. Her involvement in the ensemble and her blossoming friendship with Reina more or less happened to her instead of her actively working towards some goal. But during the first season she found her love for the ensemble and found a new friend (or new love, some might say, I guess) in Reina. At the end of the first season music and the ensemble became things she cared for and was passionate about. In that regard, the flashbacks from episode 08 feel like a retcon. Suddenly Kumiko had always been a BIG fan of music and her sister had actually inspired her to start playing music as well. As far as I remember, that story sounded VERY different when Kumiko told it during the first season. The general tone back then made Kumiko seem laid-back and disinterested. Now all of a sudden her sister’s life is supposed to have had a huge impact on Kumiko’s attitude towards music. When Shuu says to Kumiko’s sister how she has always admired her and had always wanted to play music with her together, I’m just left wondering “Where is this coming from?!”. Sure, this does add depth to Kumiko’s character but it certainly hadn’t been there before in that form, which is the reason why it feels like a retcon.

It often feels like the series is hitting you over the head with its story these days. Mostly it’s the series’ fault for not evolving its ideas or how it approaches the already existing ones. Every obstacle in the story doesn’t lead forward but is treated like a blemish of dirt on a static idea of what the school-ensemble and its characters should be like. Whatever depth there is doesn’t lead to captivating storytelling due to a combination of sluggish storytelling and heavy-handed symbolism. The lack of subtlety in the recent episodes makes it easy to sit in judgment of the characters who don’t deal with the seemingly obvious problem directly. Instead of empathy, it’s simply impatience that settles in after every time Kumiko doesn’t find anything of note to say in response to the drama unfolding in front of her.

Episodes-Rating: 5th Episode 5/10 6th Episode 6.5/10 7th/8th Episode 5.5/10

Random Thoughts:

  • Reina giving Kumiko the same CD she has gotten from her teacher makes no sense… unless Hibike! Euphonium is planning on adding magic to its setting.
  • Good thing we get a ton of flashbacks about how much Kumiko has always wanted to play music because of her sister. But when her sister is making the argument that she gave up the trombone because of her parents, her father is like “Nope, that was all you, kid.” and that’s it. Maybe a flashback illuminating that would’ve been more relevant story-wise…? Now the tension of that arc is kept up in part by withholding that information. Because all this little story-arc has to offer is to find out what is really going on and then confront that issue.
  • Also, Kumiko’s character in the first episode of the first season is the complete opposite of chibi-Kumiko. You know, I really don’t like when flashbacks also have build-up as if they’re little story-arcs of their own when functionally they’re just there to inform the present-day-narrative.
  • On a side-note: Maybe Westworld is doing something similar but at least you’re getting something out of each scene no matter what is happening chronologically.
  • The behavior of Asuka’s mom in that teacher-lounge was… embarrassing, to say the least. She seemed narcissistic (everything seemed to be about her in her mind), slapped her kid, started shouting AND it all happened in front of an “audience”: Way to go, Asuka’s mom!
  • Well, at least we get to see Shuu a little bit more now. The series certainly could do more to make him a more relevant character because of his connection to Kumiko but hey, it’s better than nothing.
  • The concert in episode 05 was another well-animated moment in this series. But we’ve seen this kind of scene before which doesn’t make it any less good-looking but certainly less impressive.
  • That moment before the concert where you see all these girls talk to each other in pairs (the direction and especially the cinematography give you that impression)… and the fact that Reina suddenly decides she isn’t playing just for herself after all and her two candidates are Kumiko and Taki instead (and she even decides to settle on Kumiko because playing for Taki would be more suitable for a stuffy ballad)… I really don’t know how this scene could be more yuri-esque than that. It’s a scene overflowing with intimacy instead of mere friendship. Because of moments like this, people will continue to call this series yuri-bait.

About M0rg0th

We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.

Posted on November 24, 2016, in Anime, Hibike! Euphonium, Reviews and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.

  1. The only reason to watch this show is for Kyoto Animation’s usual bang-up job of production. The story is hardly worthy of a Saturday morning kid’s cartoon.

    Might I suggest you turn your critical faculties to one of the season’s more compelling shows, like Flip Flappers or Yuri on Ice? While both have their warts, the storytelling and sheer passion put into each makes them both infinitely more interesting to watch.

    Like

    • Flip Flappers comes tomorrow ^^ . I’m currently reading “Magic As Metaphor In Animes: A Critical Study” from Dani Cavallaro. The last part is a bit of a misnomer, though, because there’s nothing critical about that author’s rose-tinted glasses when it comes to animes, like arguing that the OP of Ghost Hunt from JC Staff looks cheap on purpose for example *facepalm*. And I want to kill the editor who allowed him to waste SO many pages on describing the plot of the animes he talks about.

      But there are some illuminating ideas in there about how magic works in a lot of animes and how this relates to Shintoism and Buddhism. Especially his ideas on why magic is so often presented as a contract in animes are interesting. At least in that regard, it’s a good read.

      I want to finish that first because it relates to what Flip Flappers is doing.

      Like

  2. It’s been a while since your last review about Hibike! Euphonium. It’s sad that you didn’t really enjoy theses episodes. I think that after episode 5 the show is becoming better.

    Episode 5 was not bad but right after the Mizore arc that annoyed me a lot, I didn’t feel impressed by their performance. Sure it was longer than the one in the last episode of season 1, but nothing incredible. They also reused some scenes so we barely got anything new. And Reina saying she’s playing for Kumiko, geez… Please stop with that yuri bait, it’s annoying! Also, with the previous nonsense drama, I couldn’t feel happy for them succeeding. At the end of the episode I was just like “Ok, they won, they’re going to the nationals…”

    Episode 6 was better, we got some music in the start, then it was kinda funny to see everybody doing their activities for the school festival. Sapphire and Hazuki got more screentime, Natsuki was funny teasing Yuuko to eat her Pisa Tower, Asuka and Haruka looked very good as witches… And we also get to see Shuuichi in the haunted house!
    Then in the second half we learn more about Taki. I expected that his wife was dead but it was interesting to learn why he came to Kitauji.

    Episodes 7 and 8 are more focused on Asuka and Mamiko’s problems which are the pressure of their parents. Asuka’s mom wants her to quit the band since it reminds her of Asuka’s father (don’t know much about him but she raised Asuka alone), and she also wants her daughter to focus on her studies. Asuka don’t show up for training because of that and people are sad about it, especially Haruka, but they don’t give up and I really liked their performance in episode 7 (probably the best of the show). But still, Asuka’s problem isn’t solved and everybody worries about her. Her attitude isn’t the best because she’s saying she won’t cause problems but at the same time she doesn’t show up and don’t tell her friends about her situation. We are shown that she’s far from being perfect, but she’s still an interesting character.
    Mamiko’s problem is similar, she’s under her parents pressure. She didn’t want to quit playing the trombone but entered college because her parents wanted to. Ok she should have said it sooner but as the older sister it is understandable that she wanted to be an example for a sister by listening to her parents. But the dad is understandable too, he’s paying for her tuition so if she stops going to college, it will be a waste. While Kumiko is sick, Reina comes to visit her and sees the two sisters arguing. But she also hears Mamiko and Shuuichi’s discussion (the best part of the episode since Shuuichi is the one who clearly says to Mamiko that she has inspired Kumiko). I didn’t think that the flash back with little Kumiko were like “fillers” because we understand that when she was a kid, she wanted to play music like her sister and with her. Knowing the fact that Mamiko probably quit playing the trombone right after high school or maybe earlier is she was forced to quit before her exams… and that she’s 5-6 years older than Kumiko, Kumiko was probably starting middle school at that time. So when Mamiko quit playing the trombone Kumiko became less enthusiastic about music until high school (as we see at the start of the first season). But then she regained that love for music thanks to her friends, including Reina, and the rest of the band. And thanks to Shuuichi, Mamiko is now aware of Kumiko’s feelings. He’s definitely the best lol

    To be short, theses episodes are better than the previous arc since the drama is not overdone. I find it kinda realistic since they emphasize the pressure from the parents on their children so that they can focus more on their studies (in Asuka and Mamiko’s cases), and we also get to see Aoi who is doing well in her extra classes. It isn’t a problem unique to Japan. I know people who were strained to do what their parents chose for them. It’s sad but it happens everywhere. And I like how the show is conveying that since it is more realistic than the stupid misunderstanding about Mizore and Nozomi.

    Hope we’ll see Shuuichi a lot more. =)

    Like

    • „And Reina saying she’s playing for Kumiko, geez… Please stop with that yuri bait, it’s annoying!“

      With Hibike Euphonium I’ve found out that the only thing worse than encoded yuri-esque fanservice is badly encoded yuri-fanservice. It’s like they aren’t even aware of the fact that they’ve left subtext behind and the yuri simply becomes text sometimes. Why would Reina say that? Especially since the previous episode had ended with Reina saying she’s playing for herself! It makes no sense! I bet the novel has a better explanation for that change but again you get adaptation-choices that favor the yuri-parts for no substantial reason (it isn’t like the series actually wants to have a yuri-romance-plotline).

      “At the end of the episode I was just like “Ok, they won, they’re going to the nationals…” “

      I agree. And this highlights my general feelings on this show perfectly. Imagine if this series had aired uninterrupted for 20 weeks: I would be SO tired of this “Let’s go to the Nationals!”-spiel, I probably would’ve dropped the series already. The break softened my feelings in this regard certainly. But still, this show has evolved SO little – despite the fact that it has characters who develop and a solid main-plot.

      The show hasn’t raised the stakes for any upcoming challenge. With the Asuka-arc it’s just another girl with another problem. I mean, with such a thin narrative-structure, each arc solely depends on the likeability of the arc’s “problem-child”. And what I also didn’t like about the Mizore-arc was how it introduced new characters for that role. How the hell is this series ever going to have the ensemble be a good “character” as a group when the series pulls shit like that? Because you know, technically you should get to a point where you can have group-scenes where multiple characters can contribute without any big exposition or plot-maneuvering. This is where the plot can move more fluidly around these known quantities (ie everything the series had already established previously) and the story can bank on the audience caring about what’s going on. Instead the series seems to be stuck in some sort of formula where the main-plot (going to the Nationals) is more or less just there to be a clock for the narrative.

      “So when Mamiko quit playing the trombone Kumiko became less enthusiastic about music until high school (as we see at the start of the first season).”

      And that’s the ONLY Kumiko-part that matters. The rest should focus on Mamiko. And wouldn’t it be a far cooler plottwist for Mamiko to realize on her own that she’s the reason Kumiko had lost her love for music? Instead of having this tedious flashback-sequence

      I was thinking recently how different this series would be if we’d actually start following whoever the “problem-child” is as the new protagonist for each arc. Imagine these recent two episodes with Asuka or Mamiko as protagonists and maybe the story would be them helping each other and relating to each other. Like this scene where Asuka’s mom flips out and somehow it would’ve been Mamiko being there (because she had to bring something to Kumiko or something like that). And Mamiko would’ve proceeded to yell at the mom saying everything she had always wanted to say to her own parents. But from there it isn’t about rescuing Asuka or Mamiko rediscovering her love for music, it’s about both reconciling the wishes of their parents with their own wishes. And it ends with them both finding compromises that make both them and their parents happy.

      Of course, this is more or less just a fanfic-idea and not really a criticism. But what struck me about this was how as far as this story-arc is concerned everything else besides the Asuka/Mamiko-stuff is more or less extraneous. It isn’t relevant how good the ensemble is and how close they are to winning the Nationals. And frankly, Kumiko is only relevant in how Mamiko has affected her. But the series needlessly complicates its narrative by focusing on Kumiko.

      “It isn’t a problem unique to Japan. I know people who were strained to do what their parents chose for them. It’s sad but it happens everywhere. And I like how the show is conveying that since it is more realistic than the stupid misunderstanding about Mizore and Nozomi.”

      I agree 100% but I really don’t like how that story is told here. After two episodes it’s still unclear why the narrative needed to have this double-team of similar cases at its center. The series hasn’t gained anything by dividing its attention like that.

      “Hope we’ll see Shuuichi a lot more.”

      It’s a bit stereotypical that the one dude in the cast is the one who’s clear-headed and doesn’t react emotionally but in that Mamiko-scene you certainly understand what position he’s supposed to fill in the series.

      Like

Please Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: